Get Cracking About 1-2-3 Choices

The Oakland City Council has now green-lighted ranked choice voting for November’s election, based on a vote of six aye’s and two nay’s.  That means four years will have transpired between voter approval and implementation, as the wheels of democracy turn slowly between the state and city.

What is this kind of voting?  Well, it’s a ballot that enables voters to select their first, second and third choices.  It’s a procedure which eliminates primaries and opens up the candidate pool as well.  Try out this San Francisco educational demo here.

Oaklanders Voted For Ranked Choice

Some 69 percent of voters approved Measure O to alter and consolidate our local election cycle, back in 2006.  The Secretary of State finally authorized the change in December, and the Council’s blessed things tonight.  To remind everyone, here’s what voters approved:

This proposed Charter amendment would require the City to use a ranked choice voting method, known sometimes as instant runoff voting, to elect the offices of Mayor, Council, City Attorney, City Auditor and Board of Education at November general elections, which would eliminate June primary elections for these offices.

Tonight’s Discussion and Vote

We watched many citizens address the City Council, often representing groups concerned about voter education and outreach.  The League of Women Voters’ president stepped up the podium and declared that “we’re prepared together with all the other community-based groups.”

Council members also took their time sharing views about voter turnout.  Their discussion then touched on the direct, unbudgeted costs to switch over:  it could run $1.5 million, or less when (most likely) shared with other Alameda County cities, namely Berkeley and San Leandro.

After all was said and done, the Council acknowledged many more voters would turn out in November rather than June – and that would make a big difference in voting outcomes.  Council members knew they needed to support the voter mandate too.

A Bigger, Welcoming Tent

We listened closely to the City Council members, and their comments reflected the need to create a bigger, welcoming tent filled with candidates and voters.  The voting change allowed them to get on soapboxes.

Rep Nancy Nadel explained “it’s less expensive for the candidate, and that’s when you get real grass-roots policy makers coming forward.”  Our rep, Jean Quan, supported the power of coalitions and said the upcoming election must “have the most amount of people involved, of all kinds.”

Rep Desley Brooks focused on voter engagement.  “It is true that November elections have more people who participate,” said Brooks, but “that’s not because of ranked choice voting.”  Rep Rebecca Kaplan sought additional outreach efforts, perhaps by redirecting Oakland’s matching grant money to groups like the NAACP, Unity Council, or Oakland Rising.

All things return to Oakland’s budget deficit, currently pegged at around $12 million or so.  Reps Ignacio De La Fuente and Jane Brunner wanted to understand any incremental costs, this year.  As a voter mandate, the switch would come down to making other trade-offs and cuts soon – always about the money.

More info:  RCV Status ReportDe La Fuente LetterVoter Mandate Recap

One thought on “Get Cracking About 1-2-3 Choices

  1. I too listened carefully to all of the city council representatives and their LONG comments, sometimes rambling, repetitive and far off the subject. has reported gently on their comments. If you want a ringside seat at the Oakland City Council in action, watch the KTOP TV replay of last night’s city council meeting. No need to watch the long parade of citizens that took place before the city council members started in on a subject that seemed to me to be beyond discussion. All they had to do was vote on what we the voters had already decided. No, all the hidden agendas were in play last night.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s